Malaysia Grand Prix 2012, Kuala Lumpur - Race 2/20

Ferrari ditching pull rod suspension shocker?. I said it wouldn't work and no one believed me. With a low nose maybe, but with a high nose there isn't enough angle on that pull rod for it to work properly.

Have they said they will ditch it? Can't see it happening during the season?
 
Have a look at Massa's results before and after the accident. Before he was regularly getting podiums and race wins. He's not won a single race since the accident, now - okay - Ferrari haven't been as hot 2010 and 2011, but they've still notched up wins and good points. Massa hasn't.

So, yes, it's speculation but dismissing it as "pure" speculation is ignoring the facts. Massa, whether because of the accident or for another reason, hasn't performed since his return in 2010 to the levels he managed beforehand. The natural conclusion is that something about the accident, whether the faintest hint of extra caution or lasting damage from his injuries, has caused that decline.

In my opinion, I don't think that the accident affected his confidence as he actually came back from it very well with a 2nd place in the opening GP of 2010, then a 3rd place in Aus. In total he had 4 podiums and 13 top 10 finishes.

The biggest changes since then are a) The car isn't as good b) the calibre of competition is higher.

The 2010 car wasn't great (good, but not the fastest). Massa was around 3 to 4 tenths off Alonso.

Here are Massa's results before the accident:

DNF, 9th, DNF, 14th, 6th 4th, 6th, 4th, 4rd

Here are Massa's results after the accident:

2nd, 3rd, 7th, 9th, 6th, 4th 7th, 15th, 11th,


So immediately on his return he enjoyed two podiums (compared to Alonso's 3). In total he had 4 podiums and 13 top 10 finishes. That was decent enough.

Really it was late 2010 and 2011 where Massa appeared to become unstuck.
 
Have they said they will ditch it? Can't see it happening during the season?

Lot's of rumours in Italian media that they will ditch it and have a new chassis around Spain, Ferrari keep denying it but generally the Italian media tends to be right more often than not :D
 
Have they said they will ditch it? Can't see it happening during the season?

When would it be for? Is changing the front suspension something they can engineer into this chassis, or would they need to redesign the whole front end of the tub (and therefore the whole tub)? Be impressed to see how quickly they can turn it around if its a tub redesign.
 
If it's a tub redesign I wonder if they'll get rid of the horrific nose seeing as it definitely seems any advantage of the ugliness is negligible at best...
 
If it's a tub redesign I wonder if they'll get rid of the horrific nose seeing as it definitely seems any advantage of the ugliness is negligible at best...

With the fundamental design principle being based around having a high nose, the most they could likely do is round it off a bit. Its still going to be a platypus nose.
 
Last edited:
Lot's of rumours in Italian media that they will ditch it and have a new chassis around Spain, Ferrari keep denying it but generally the Italian media tends to be right more often than not :D

If this happens, in essence all the hard work they did last year (remember, they stopped development of last year's car about mid-way through the season to concentrate on the 2012 car), will almost, have been in vain.

All that hard work and then to complete ditch the car. If it were me, I would find it difficult to swallow.

I'm still hoping that they learn more about the car and then as if by magic, suddenly begin to make it work.
 
Well if the car is not going to work then it's been in vain anyway, no point going on with a project that is a dead end and not going to be winning. Ferrari have denied it anyway so we shall see, I expect they will have some big changes to the exhaust and floor in China.
 
The mid and rear of the car would still be the same? So development on that wouldn't be wasted. Depends whether they just change the suspension layout or the whole front aero (Mclaren style) I guess.
 
Front aero is a massive change. The layout would be much simpler.

Just a thought on the whole aero style, will the 2014 rules on lower nose tips effectively force everyone down the McLaren style route? If so McLaren are going to be up to 6 years a head in terms of development around that style.
 
When would it be for? Is changing the front suspension something they can engineer into this chassis, or would they need to redesign the whole front end of the tub (and therefore the whole tub)? Be impressed to see how quickly they can turn it around if its a tub redesign.

Would they change the suspension?

At the last GP Martin Brundle, said that in all his experience he's never heard of a change of suspention making an F1 car faster. In his opinion the car has fundemantal areo problems and rear end mechanical grip issues.

Of course he's just a former driver, but i presume he knows roughly what he's talking about given his role.

This wouldn't be the first season there have been rumours of a 'new' car at Ferrari in-season. I don't remember, but did the other rumours ever come ture?
 
No been years since they had a B chassis mid season, think was when Alesi was drivng. In the Schumi era they did tend to start the season with a B chassis from the previous year then bring the new car, ah the good old days :D
 
This discussion has been kicked off by the rumour that Ferrari are ditching the pull rod suspension. No idea how true it is, but its an interesting and radical direction change if so.

I seem to remember a lot of people used to run 'B Spec' cars in the past, but its not something I have heard of at all in recent years. There also used to be a trend of running the old car at the start of the new season, and that no longer happens either, although likely because the rules have not remained static enough to allow it.

If Ferrari are positive they have got it wrong then I can easily see them pulling out a B spec car. They have the resources to do it, and the pressure from themselves and Italy as a whole to push them.
 
Ferrari ditching pull rod suspension shocker?. I said it wouldn't work and no one believed me. With a low nose maybe, but with a high nose there isn't enough angle on that pull rod for it to work properly.

as i see it there isnt any difference between pullrod and pushrod in terms of geometry, both will move the rocker the same amount, the angle of the pullrod to the nose isnt important its the angle relevant to the other suspension components and thats all fine on the ferrari. Its not to say though that the pullrod design isnt giving them some issues with the way the chassis is loaded and its a result of that, or with the aero or something, but maybe they just lack overall downforce, the fact they have been playing around with different exhaust solutions would suggest they are trying to find more rear downforce.
 
The main issue with the Ferraris appear to be the rear end. The front end might be influencing the problem though?

We shall have to wait and see. Some rumours say new chassis for China, some say for Spain.
 
Back
Top Bottom