Not to offend Porsche?...
It's a better car than the previous generation, which was the best in it's class. Of course it's going to get good reviews.
What I mean by that is most of them seems to skate around the engine noise as not one of them have come and directly and said its sounds rubbish. As I guess in many ways that would be a little unprofessional. However, I’d rather the motoring press be direct and state the good and bad points clearly.
Matt Prior even states in the review "In my mind this is still one of the greatest open top sports cars you can buy no question. Am I enjoying that motor? (A long pause) I think I’d be enjoying if it had two more cylinders and one less turbo."
I think you can agree that above review isn't really glowing is it? When you compare it to the reviews of like mine for example.
Again the PH review is more or less the same.
It's technically better than your GTS in suspension, power delivery, interior design and infotainment. The only thing you could hold against it is the weaker sounding engine.
Yes, I won’t dispute that fact in terms of engineering it is an improvement but a better sports car I’m not sure.
However, given the choice both the 981 and the 718 (982) I’d still choose mine over the new car and that’s a view held by many people when looking on various forums. Also interest at the OPC's has been low on the 718's again that isn't a great sign.
Another gripe I have also going back to the motor again, how many people are going to pay 50K + (As we all know there are Porsche options) for a 4 pot turbo, it’s a step too much. IMO.
When you think of a sports car? What are the key factors you think about?
As for me, it doesn’t need to be the fastest thing on the road but it should bring a sense of occasion and enjoyment from the car.
Maybe they will bring out a GTS with a NA engine at some point.
It would really make sense if they had a 3.4 NA engine in the Boxter and Cayman GTS and a 3.8 in the 911 GTS.
It would be lovely to see that as id upgrade in a flash! Sadly I can't see that happening but I await with bated breath on that one as I know there have been rumours.
However, I can see the NA motors going in the GT cars and other special edidtions which saidly is going to push the price through the roof (Flippers).