Well I for one am absolutely loving this game, despite being very skeptical about it early on...
People are slating this game as trash because it has "no content" and meanwhile heralding a game like Far Cry 5 as incredible, seemingly oblivious to the irony that really it's not all that different... Sprinkle a ton of collectibles and copy pasted uninspired sidequests, then tac on an arbitrary XP/skill levelling system and suddenly you've got depth and an amazing game do you? I'll take chasing and ambushing other ships and messing about on the high seas with a crew of mates over mowing down another band of samey poor-AI enemies to clear another outpost/checkpoint and getting a pat on the head like I accomplished something any day of the week...
To be clear I'm still not saying I agree with the price of SoT and I also do still hope the devs release some more gameplay related things to do over time, but the foundation is solid and more fun than countless games in recent memory. Just last night we were saying it might be the most enjoyable group game to kill time and mess around on since the glory days of TF2