I'm not arguing with that, but if everyone had that mentality... than we would never have Civic's running 1/4 mile in the region of 7s. Looking outside the box is a good thing, going down the same route as everyone else is boring.to those about the mk5, they were never designed for straight line speed, they didnt become best in its class for overtaking ability now did they and a supercharger would suit them better than a turbo.
BTW I hate the supercharger wine, went to see a IS200 supercharged the other week. I'm not a fan of superchargers I'll tell you that much...