@Gibbo
Lotus or Boxster?
You can have only one, because those are the rules of my highly unique game.
As a daily car, the Boxster wins this quite easily. The Boxster / Spyder has pretty amazing mechanical traction in all conditions, helped greatly by been shod in PS4S tyres. Then factor in it has pretty amazing luggage ability with two decent sized boots, very cheap running cost, two yearly servicing which is typically sub £500, so £250 a year in servicing, insurance is also pretty cheap at around £500 with track cover and the 987.2/997.2 generation cars are considered as the most reliable that Porsche ever built. The other fantastic thing about the Spyder and Cayman R is though they are very much like a GT car in ways of weight reduction and tweaks, they are serviced as regular Boxster and Cayman keeping the prices down, because engines wise they are the same, just like a 10HP boost and some nice weight savings.
I will say anyone wanting a road car that is fun at legal speeds and doubles as a superb track car, there really is no better car than a Cayman R or Boxster Spyder, there is a reason they still cost now used what they did new and in some cases more, they are worth every penny. Some argue but are they worth double that of a regular Cayman/Boxster, well only you as a buyer can decide that but I think for the Spyder absolutely as it looks so much better than a Boxster and looks superb roof up as well.
So a road car with some track use the Boxster is hard to beat for its all round ease of use.
However as a truly special track and weekend only car, Exige all day long, I've now done dry track days in both and the Exige is just totally exhilarating machine to drive, it turns into the race car it is with a set of number plates. It may not be quite on GT3 RS pace, but I do think its more fun and a more involving drive, namely because of that third pedal and stick, but it is also a car that takes time to build upto but rewards all the more so for doing so. Not to say the Porsche Spyder is bad on track, it was truly sensational as well, especially having the ceramic brake option which transforms the brakes on a Boxster as they literally double in size, as the regular steel brakes on a Boxster/Cayman are not upto track work out the box, but the ceramics do so easily especially in a car only weighing 1275kg. Brakes are so important and by some miracle the Exige has even superior braking in the dry, no doubt helped by only been around 1100kg, wearing cup 2 tyres and been a combination of AP calipers and Alcon disc I believe, though could be AP all round, either way the stopping power is amazing.
They are both superb, I'd say the Boxster is a lot more friendly for mucking around in, you can pull absolutely huge slip angles and recover it, the chassis is probably one of the best out there, but the Exige is more reqarding when you absolutely nail that apex, put in a great lap and has a bigger learning curve. Both look incredible but the Exige looks proper race car and the noise that supercharged V6 emits at full howl is just legendary. Now I've driven the Exige in the dry I feel it may be the one I keep and I end up selling the Emira as the latter will have to be so damn good on track to make me want to move the Exige on. If the Exige was my only car I would absolutely buy another set of wheels shod in a more appropriate road tyre and its luggage capacity is rather poor and its not the kind of car your mother can get in or get out of.
Unfortunately I never recorded my Donnington laps in the Spyder or my last sessions in the Exige when I went solo, which was a mistake on the latter as I started to drum up enough confidence to go chasing and pretty much keeping up with the GT3 RS boys, if I do end up keeping the Exige it will certainly be getting the EX475 power package.