Silo - By Hugh Howey - May 5th

Was going to wait until S2 finished, but binged all 3 episodes tonight! I thought ep 1 was fine, ep 2 and the bridge building was not needed! But back on track for ep 3.

Was the rope cut? We have people dead outside the hatch and graffiti from the silo people, it looked from the camera angles that someone was watching them - are there still inhabitants in the silo?

Also, Juliet's Silo needs many teams to run, why do we still have light, power and oxygen in the decimated silo?

It does, but it also has the strain of a single person using power/resources.

There's certainly an argument there but I'm viewing this thus far as a very brutal testing ground for events I'm not sure the current cast are actually experiencing, I've not read the source but it feels artificial and intentional to me in the way a crazy dystopian testing ground might.
Book spoilers to follow (though how much of this makes it in the show remains to be seen):
Jimmy/Solo's father was the overseer of Silo 17. When things went pear shaped and he knew the bossmen in Silo 1 would hit the kill switch and nanogas the inhabitants, he arranged for Jimmy to be locked in the secure area. Those outside and by the airlock were killed by the fact the airlock doesn't release a cleaning spray but the nano's which also replenishes the cloud of nanogas over the Silo area. And there's a little sting in the tale for anyone thinking about going back in through an operational airlock, too! Hint, wrap yoourself in something very heat and flame proof...

Despite the purge there were a number of other survivors who attempted to get in, they kept numerically incrementing the door code (one try allowed a day) until they hit the correct one. At which point Jimmy had to kill them or be killed.
In the books, the bridge to the rest of the Silo wasn't damaged, only the lower levels were flooded. So Jimmy could move around freely. There are other survivors in 17, group of children/teenagers but Jimmy wasn't aware of them until he started helping Juliette in here endeavours to drain the flood, when they attacked him - though it all worked out okay in the end. Whether they appear in the show remains to be seen.

The motive behind creating the Silo's was to purify the human race to eliminate conflict and all the flaws of mid 21st Century humanity. If I remember the books correctly, only one Silo out of the 50 would be chosen to eventually repopulate the species, as it were. We probably won't see the machinations of those running Silo 1 and indeed the project (via periods of prolonged cryosleep) in S2 but it is quite fascinating and it really puts the pieces of the puzzle together. Would recommend giving the books a read for a bit of insight into events being portrayed in the show.
 
Last edited:
Gawd this is so boring.

Dont remember series 1 being so slow and generally uninteresting.

After two episodes setting the scene I was expecting things to take off a bit in Ep 3 but no - just more of the same.
 
Gawd this is so boring.

Dont remember series 1 being so slow and generally uninteresting.

After two episodes setting the scene I was expecting things to take off a bit in Ep 3 but no - just more of the same.
I don't know. After reading the books, the first season in retrospect was very padded out and a lot of elements added for effect - such as replacing the commutater on the generator which in the book was very much just a mundane everyday task. No high drama involved.

Anyhow looking forward to tonight's episode.
 
you never watched MacGyver?

this is going to be one of those series where they just keep delaying and putting off anything good for as long as possible.
 
Average episode IMHO. I mean obviously I'm now watching with the hindsight of the books but it seemed to drift a little. Following in particular:

I don't recall Jimmy/Solo scuttling back to the Control Centre like a panicked child. In fact
He was knocked out by the teenagers and children who suddenly appeared, thus no longer pumping air to Juliet). In the books he was quite resourceful and the entrance code was embedded in his mind, having watched previously each day as the survivors ouside incremented the number trying to get in.

Juliet was trying to get the pumps going to drain the water not just to grab the firefighters outfit.

Over in 18 the events were greatly ramped up from the book, all the intrigue and lethal actions simply didn't happen at that point.
 
I think they over sold the bridge building to show the audience how resourceful she is. Solo is fascinated by her ability to engineer / create things in the book.
They established this is S1 in the 1st episode when we were introduced to her. And sticking a few poles together with black nasty is hardly the skills of an elite engineer. The Silo needs Colin Furze in there.
 
Really struggled through episode 4, took 3 attempts over the last few days to watch it as it just wasn't holding my attention despite I quite liked the slower, moody, exploration in 1-3.
 
I'm loving this season, more action packed and suspenseful than S1.

I thought I've been paying attention, but all episode long I thought her pains were gonna be pregnancy related or she has the condition that Billings has. Clearly she shows some sort of injury she picked up on her arm, but I can't recall how or when that happened, assuming it happened on screen in the last couple of episodes?


rp2000
 
Last edited:
I'm loving this season, more action packed and suspenseful than S1.

I thought I've been paying attention, but all episode long I thought her pains were gonna be pregnancy related or she has the condition that Billings has. Clearly she shows some sort of injury she picked up on her arm, but I can't recall how or when that happened, assuming it happened on screen in the last couple of episodes?


rp2000

I thought it maybe the virus/poison effecting her - leading to surviving > building immunity > walking outside without a suit > she is the messiah and her bloods are cultured leading to a cure.

Maybe i'm trying to think too far ahead and that is complete ******.

Did enjoy Ep5 more than the last few eps.
 
Last edited:
Dont remember series 1 being so slow and generally uninteresting.
it really reminds me of that series about the boring train in the snow this season.

Class wars are just so boring.
The series would be better if it was just Juliett exploring silos on her own with no other cast apart from flash backs to how the silos were and what happened...

lower class vs upper class, is just boring too many series do it lazily


Half a season gone and nothing happened, why would anyone want s03? it's just going through the motions
 
Last edited:
it really reminds me of that series about the boring train in the snow this season.

Class wars are just so boring.
The series would be better if it was just Juliett exploring silos on her own with no other cast apart from flash backs to how the silos were and what happened...

lower class vs upper class, is just boring too many series do it lazily


Half a season gone and nothing happened, why would anyone want s03? it's just going through the motions
It's based of a book of a stratified society... how exactly are they going to just ignore the premise of the story?

There are only 6 stories to be told.
 
I thought it maybe the virus/poison effecting her - leading to surviving > building immunity > walking outside without a suit > she is the messiah and her bloods are cultured leading to a cure.

Maybe i'm trying to think too far ahead and that is complete ******.

Did enjoy Ep5 more than the last few eps.
Except it's actually a nano virus so not sure you can build immunity to that. Unless of course the TV adaptation is changing that aspect of the story from the books. It is released every time an airlock is opened which is why, when it cycles closed, the airlock interior has to be fire flashed to destroy the little boogers.
 
Hmm.. I find the second series so far - she's just finished diving. To be .. a dull fest. Not that I think Rebecca Fergusson is dull but the plot needs a defibrillator.
 
Watched Episode 5 and not feeling much love for the adaptation at all.

They are ruining Solo's character from the book, constantly throwing tantrums and chucking his Teddy, when he was quite calm and collected. I can't recall at what point he revealed his name was Jimmy but at no point did he pretend to be someone else.

18 is also massively altered and "sexed up" from the books. Yes there was dissent but the prominence being given to Sims (I don't even think he was in the book) and
making him Judge
is total invention.

The producers and writers doing the adaptation really need to pull back to the source material IMHO, rather than rewriting much of the story.
 
Back
Top Bottom