Soldato
The Spock close up and eyebrow raise was perfectly in keeping with the original. If you weren't aware this episode was a retelling of the TOS Balance of Terror but with Pike instead of Kirk. If you haven't seen it it's worth watching to get the changes and what causes the war etc.
All of those little camera push-ins, the way characters were lit, the timing of the camera pan, all of it cribbed so hard from the direction on "Balance of Terror" that Vincent McEveety should have gotten a nod in the credits