Star Wars: The Acolyte (it’s dead Jim)
- Thread starter Bigpig
- Start date
Caporegime
:/
Caporegime
We don't know yet, that's the mystery.
I don't see how they butcher the lore either, force users that aren't jedi or sith are well established in the lore.
I don't see how they butcher the lore either, force users that aren't jedi or sith are well established in the lore.
Caporegime
="i assume the big reactor thing blew up... nothign esle makes sense.. lol "]
but to justify what the 4 main jedi felt so guilty i can only assume they rigged the place to burn/blow... because otherwise wtf are they guilty of???
I guess they got mind tricked into fighting each other and killed everyone?? lol f knows....
Last edited:
Its not explained but given the trash writing it wouldn't be surprising that they are hinting the jedi did it, because the Jedi are the bad guys all along.
You wouldnt
Caporegime
You got a genuine argument or are you just trolling?
What me?? I am am genuinely perplexed.
Caporegime
I'm pretty sure lesbians aren't banned in star wars. And there is literally existing lore for a child created from the force lol.
You mean like Anakin thought he was as well.
Last edited:
WAIT? THAT'S IT??? THAT WAS THE BIG REVEAL?
So the Jedi weren't to blame, Mae was a psychopath and killed everyone and now she blames the 4 Jedi for her screw up? Are you serious? Why did one of them even take the poison then??
It makes NO DAMN SENSE!!!
So they either secretly sabotaged it or it wasn't their fault. Either way, it doesn't make sense for Mae to blame the Jedi because she doesn't have the knowledge of sabotage even if they did do it. It's so obvious they#re going to retcon that the Jedi was responsible somehow but the whole coven of witches trying to force their kids into an ideology and asking them to lie is giving off real vibe of Jazz Jennings mom about it.
So the Jedi weren't to blame, Mae was a psychopath and killed everyone and now she blames the 4 Jedi for her screw up? Are you serious? Why did one of them even take the poison then??
It makes NO DAMN SENSE!!!
Mae started a fire that eventually blew up the reactor, killing everyone. You can see the hole in the wall with the rubble blown outwards and everyone dead, Mae didn't say it was the Jedi either.
So they either secretly sabotaged it or it wasn't their fault. Either way, it doesn't make sense for Mae to blame the Jedi because she doesn't have the knowledge of sabotage even if they did do it. It's so obvious they#re going to retcon that the Jedi was responsible somehow but the whole coven of witches trying to force their kids into an ideology and asking them to lie is giving off real vibe of Jazz Jennings mom about it.
Last edited:
Caporegime
They did not show that in the episode at all.
It seemed like there is no big reveal, which is a bit weird.
However, there was a period of time they skipped before Osha wakes up on their ship. Maybe we'll see another flashback later as the twist.
I don't see how the fire could have killed the witches, the way the bodies were strewn on the floor, but maybe i'm overthinking it.
It was an average episode overall. Not bad, but just back story. I didn't really like the witches stuff in Ashoka and I sort of feel similar in this show. Having only watched all the live action TV and Films, I just don't know the limits/extents of their powers, whereas the whole dark light side force powers are well defined.
Edit: after seeing the screen grabs above, maybe there is no twist at all
rp2000
However, there was a period of time they skipped before Osha wakes up on their ship. Maybe we'll see another flashback later as the twist.
I don't see how the fire could have killed the witches, the way the bodies were strewn on the floor, but maybe i'm overthinking it.
It was an average episode overall. Not bad, but just back story. I didn't really like the witches stuff in Ashoka and I sort of feel similar in this show. Having only watched all the live action TV and Films, I just don't know the limits/extents of their powers, whereas the whole dark light side force powers are well defined.
Edit: after seeing the screen grabs above, maybe there is no twist at all
rp2000
Last edited:
Caporegime
You're looking at the result and assuming what happened...
Why did they not just hire identical twins to play the younger May and Osha? I guess CGI trickery was too complicated with the amount of scenes they were in together, and it was actually easier to tell them apart. But I found it really jarring that they don't look identical as kids but do as adults!
rp2000
rp2000
Last edited:
Soldato
eh ? you guys get confused about strange things
they showed it from Oshas point of view
lots of detail is missing
the generator exploding
the dead witches
why May went ****
im assuming we will find out from the other POVs (Jedi / May / Witches)
they showed it from Oshas point of view
lots of detail is missing
the generator exploding
the dead witches
why May went ****
im assuming we will find out from the other POVs (Jedi / May / Witches)
Got to admit the same sentiment. This is inane stuff. The kid acting is also poor.
I've generally enjoyed the recent SW series, Andor in particualr but this is trash
'The Acolyte' Makes Massive Retcon To Star Wars Lore, Reveals Lesbian Space Witches Created Life From The Force Long Before Darth Plagueis
'The Acolyte' has made an absolutely massive and ostensibly identity politics-motivated change to a core piece of Star Wars lore.
boundingintocomics.com
Not watched a single minute of this pish, don't think I'll bother after reading that.