Dirty yes...so was Keane tho, it doesnt mean anything. You say he hasnt proven anything, well he was the youngest captain wasnt he? Not sure on that one. Was the driving force in the Middlesborough team for years. Southgate sold him and look where they end up? Relegated, he was just the type of player they were missing last season...and a striker of course. Wigan bought him and look how they did, had a superb season under Bruce. He's 21, hungry for success and more importantly has talent. Unfortunatley a few people on this forum wouldnt know a decent player if it hit them on head!
I take it all back then, he'd be a great player to take Liverpool to league and Eruropean success.