Just finished U4 and Lost Legacy.
Predictable and one-note gameplay as per usual with the series but the chemistry and banter between characters, beautiful vistas, setpieces and the cinematics is what keeps it going and makes it better than the sum of its parts IMO.
I guess this is what separates these games from the new TR trilogy as those are compared very often. TR has supposedly deeper gameplay but the bits that Uncharted does, it just does better. Climbing/moving about is more fluid and better animated, as are the shootouts and the movement in combat. The setpieces are more impactful and the cutscenes way better done. The characters' facial animations are also a couple of notches above.
And the biggest difference... the stories are always very simple but the writing and character interaction are so head and shoulders above how flat Lara is in the new trilogy that it just hurts. Not to mention Jonah, gosh.
The gameplay itself should've been more puzzle-heavy, with more exploration and less big shootouts that I was getting tired of later on.
It's a sort of an interactive movie, kick back and relax type of affair and I enjoyed it for that. Really impressive visuals, especially in Lost Legacy and it just feels good to play when it comes to overall polish.
7/10 for U4 as it plods a little and is too long to sustain this sort of gameplay.
7.5/10 for Lost Legacy, better paced because it's much shorter, better visuals, especially later on and Chloe, Nadine and Sam work a bit better together than the cast of U4. I actually think Drake is one of the worse chars in the franchise