Just finished the story, it was definitely feeling like a bit of a chore but then picked up with a nice change of pace. I'm glad I stuck with it, incredible rollercoaster of emotions and for that you have to say bravo. It's incredibly dark and depressing though, draining is a great way to describe it.
Graphics - 10/10, undoubtedly one of the best games visually I've ever played. Stunning attention to detail. As I said earlier, hard to believe this was a last gen game. ND are masters of creating an incredibly looking game
Audio - 10/10, soundtrack immense, gunshots, environmental, rain, the sounds of enemies gargling as you slit their throats. Incredible.
Gameplay - 10/10, I love the setting, the scavenging, the combat and I feel they nailed it here
Combat - 9/10, a bit spongy as far as aim is concerned but it's so brutal and satisfying. The guns themselves feel impactful, melee combat feels good etc.
Story - ? I'm conflicted on this, there was definitely some stuff in there that was unnecessary that added nothing imo and as I've said previously im not happy with what happened to certain characters. On the other hand I can see they had to do something to get you feeling the same way Ellie does and for that it hit home for me. It's an interesting concept, to play a character at the point you despise them but the way they make it work so that the ending makes sense is well done imo.
Overall - 10/10, have to say although it was dragging a bit I couldn't put it down after a certain point. I was angry, very angry at the beginning but that waned towards the end. I'm not happy with the direction or what happened to some characters, and didn't really feel the same attachment to Abby/Lev as I did Joel/Ellie in the first game but I can see what they were trying to achieve and in that respect it did it's job. An amazing experience of graphics, sound and gameplay, can't believe I waited this long to play it tbh.
Hard to see where they go from here really, I wasn't that interested in the remake of TLOU given I've played it countless times but seeing what they did with the visuals and audio on this game I think I'll have to play it. Along with, assumedly, improved controller feedback it could be amazing.