I recall the die hard Tolkien fans absolutely frothing about any change or inconsistency from the books when the PJ movies first came out. I guess this is the just the latest thing to hate on before it's even out? I myself loved both.
The star wars movies weren't dumpster fires because of Daisy Ridleys acting or her character knew how to fight (she can clearly handle herself prior to any force shenanigans), they were dumpster fires because of the badly thought out, re-hashed plots with no logic or flow to them ("somehow palpatine is back", er you wot mate?). You could make the same criticisms of Luke in the OT, he took out Death Stars and Darth Vaders for fun and had zero training prior to the movies.
Why wouldn't Galadriel be able to hold her own with a blade, where was it written she could not? She's been around so long she could have mastered any number of things. And why on (middle) earth would a female elf need to look like a Viking shield maiden? Elves who are always portrayed as moving ethereally and I suppose with cat like grace as opposed to brute forces of nature.
Honestly, people just need to chill out a bit. If it's a train wreck then at least let is crash first before getting all worked up about it.
There will lways be fans who can't accept that different mediums have different requirements.
No, the SW movies were not dumpster fires because of DR, but having a Mary-Sue was the starting point KK etc worked from, and this is the root of the problem, they begin with the messaging, the politics, the virtue-signalling and to hell with anything else, which leaves their wooden charsima vacuum of a central caratcher in a very poor position.
Why would she be able to where was it written she could? But of course amazon needs another Mary-Sue and Galadriel fits the bill. Who said anything abouit "looking like a shield maiden"?
I mereley pointed out that Lagaertha looked 100% the part of a badass female warrior, while Morfydd Clark doesn't, the harder she tries to look intimidating the less convincing it looks.
Honestly, people just need to chill out a bit. If it's a train wreck then at least let is crash first before getting all worked up about it.
No-one has forced you into this thread to discuss anything before you have seen it, and yet here you are trying to moderate discussion, it is not up to you to decide when people can discuss the show.