The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (Prime)

Permabanned
Joined
17 Sep 2022
Posts
90
Location
Wirral
Not at all, just find it surprising that a forum that is mainly for PC Hardware you create an account to come in and almost shill for a TV show that has mixed reviews on here

I can't give you a serious reply to a comment as dumb as that.

In your own mind......apparently I'm a shill for an Amazon Prime LOTR series.

Whatever....

I've got no interest in PC hardware. I'm interested in various UK forums and UK chat about general UK life and other general topics.
 
Soldato
Joined
20 Aug 2021
Posts
7,056
Location
Krypton
I can't give you a serious reply to a comment as dumb as that.

In your own mind......apparently I'm a shill for an Amazon Prime LOTR series.

Whatever....

I've got no interest in PC hardware. I'm interested in various UK forums and UK chat about general UK life and other general topics.
which other forums are you a member of? - if you don't mind me asking. If you've no interest in PC hardware how'd you find out about ocuk?
 
Associate
Joined
25 Oct 2013
Posts
1,021
Still confounded that with all the money available to them - they didnt spend a bit more on a better casting team. HOD has excellent actors throughout (whether well known or largely untried) in key roles - ROP have the usual Amazon instantly forgettable bland young things -that obviously werent quite bad enough to get the WOT gig.
 
Permabanned
Joined
17 Sep 2022
Posts
90
Location
Wirral
which other forums are you a member of? - if you don't mind me asking. If you've no interest in PC hardware how'd you find out about ocuk?

It's nice to make your acquaintance Columbo.... :)

Where else I post is none of your concern though.

How did I find overclockers and the other UK forums I post on? I googled UK CHAT FORUMS and spent some time reading the sections on those various forums to decide which ones I like and wanted to post on.

FYI....I've been posting on UK forums for over 20 years but only on 3 very specialist topics recently that aren't relevant here and I post on forums selectively as and when I choose to. I don't need permission or validation from anyone to register/post on a public forum.

I hope that answers your very personal, intrusive, and invasive question.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
20 Aug 2021
Posts
7,056
Location
Krypton
It's nice to make your acquaintance Columbo.... :)

Where else I post is none of your concern though.

How did I find overclockers and the other UK forums I post on? I googled UK CHAT FORUMS and spent some time reading the sections on those various forums to decide which ones I like and wanted to post on.

FYI....I've been posting on UK forums for over 20 years but only on 3 very specialist topics that aren't relavant here and I post on forums selectively as and when I choose to. I don't need permission or validation from anyone to register on a public forum.

I hope that answers your very personal, intrusive, and invasive question.
I hope they pay well :p
 
Soldato
Joined
20 Aug 2021
Posts
7,056
Location
Krypton
Still confounded that with all the money available to them - they didnt spend a bit more on a better casting team. HOD has excellent actors throughout (whether well known or largely untried) in key roles - ROP have the usual Amazon instantly forgettable bland young things -that obviously werent quite bad enough to get the WOT gig.
This was one of my complaints when it was announced, they've got no big names attached to the project, no-one to suck in a casual viewer through name recognition. I said it at the time but compare it to GoT and they had a slew of established big name actors.
 
Soldato
Joined
13 Mar 2007
Posts
13,827
Location
South Yorkshire
This was one of my complaints when it was announced, they've got no big names attached to the project, no-one to suck in a casual viewer through name recognition. I said it at the time but compare it to GoT and they had a slew of established big name actors.

Maybe they went after some but once they read the scripts they backed away from it.
 
Associate
Joined
2 Sep 2013
Posts
1,932
You may have a point with certain scenes, but she's just standing up here. I think this is all part of what many fans said before the show even aired based on clips and photos etc - she doesn't look the part, but of course we told to "shut up" and "wait an see"...and lo and behold here we are, she's not up to it physically or from a straight acting standpoint.

To be fair to her a lot of why she's turned into a meme machine is not her fault, miscast, trerrible writing, awful script etc I mean none of the Elves actually look like Elves, - that's not her fault.

But as C Kent alluded to, they have to do better than what she's wearing there.

Oh I never said it was directly Morfydds fault. Only that primarily through inadequacies by directors, vfx teams etc, on Amazons side, they have let the viewers down by giving us Morfydd as they are now.

1. Her physique, the selling of movement on screen, could have been improved if they wanted her to be more believable in any physical work by getting her some training and putting her in stuff that had "weight" to it (again, look back at Ep 1 for those who aren't over the series already, look at how their large swords on their back just doesn't move and moves around so quickly as they turn, it's very clearly not a real sword with any weight to it). It's been very clear other than basic typical modern human civilized healthy status, she (and others, but as she's one of the main characters, she will get the core of it) couldn't do anything that would show she has any real strength (magical strength maybe, but it's shown as YOU the viewer must simply accept it and now shown which again doesn't sell the action/scene).

Antje (who played Faora) was sent off for training with the other big hitters (Henry and Michael) for Man of Steel, and her hits/strikes, etc sold the movements as it all carried weight. VFX can only do so much to create realisim and realistic views; the best VFX has something in place that in the real world that is captured that helps with stuff like the physics of it all that it can't replace without doing it entirely in CG. Look at the scene where Steppenwolf in the Snyder Cut walks over a puddle and interrogates the Atalantian soldier on the beech; that walk over that puddle along with the twig that moved from the feets movement, whilst possible to do in CG, would have been an absolute hassle to do entirely in VFX.

2. Face acting. This is the clearly the directors and creators fault. Morfydd should not have been told to "scowl" to show anger and rage or been allowed to use that to show anger and rage, or if it was her choice to do so to show such emotion, she should have done better. But, that's what we've been given. Look back at Cate's version and we saw that she acted with her eyes and voice. Sure, that's not something everyone can do. But given Morfydds height and frame (compared to everyone else on screen), this only makes it feel like she's a little barking chihuahua, instead of a force of nature by being one of the oldest elves in existence on Middle Earth, intelligence, wise and powerful hidden inside that small stature and frame. Instead, we get what amounts (visually) a little tantrum child instead. A little showing through every so often might have been fine, but unfortunately any moment Morfydd was asked to show emotion thus far, it's been done the same way; scowl.

But this is side tracking now. Will get back to the main topics of the series itself. Another 4-5 hours before next episode. Can't wait to find what they've messed up there visually. :)
 
Soldato
Joined
28 Oct 2011
Posts
8,501
Still confounded that with all the money available to them - they didnt spend a bit more on a better casting team. HOD has excellent actors throughout (whether well known or largely untried) in key roles - ROP have the usual Amazon instantly forgettable bland young things -that obviously werent quite bad enough to get the WOT gig.

They clearly went in part for a CW vibe.
 
Soldato
Joined
26 Dec 2009
Posts
9,638
Location
North
Another excellent episode with plots moving along nicely / slowly! Thought Galadriel was much better this episode, warming up to her bit (it is what it is, I’d imagine the angelic being portrayed in LOTR would wear thin fast)

Although the mystery man plot hasn’t moved along from being a mystery man much :D aside from learning to talk!

Honestly loving the show, tuning in as soon as released which is a good sign.

They do need to get a move on as much as I like the development how the hell are we still in numenor!
 
Last edited:
Associate
Joined
2 Sep 2013
Posts
1,932
OK, so, semi spoilery since I caught it in middle of the night, so I'll stick it in spoilers, but my issues on Ep 5 (spoiler, it's nothing new from previous episodes):

1. The issue with physics remain an issue. The fight Galadriel did was... Chinese Wuxia serial level; blades had contact but no momentum that is expected from two blades clashing. When realistically people would expect the blades to wobble a little on the axis that the blades cross on (since you're striking wth a particular portion of the blade, and not from the point where the blades made contact). Blades were twirling and using the tips of the blades was able to divert and move blades in motion and keep them locked together whilst Galadrield moved them stuck to her blade(s) in the fight in all sorts of directions and angles; when again the blades would have parted from the momentum of the attackers swing. It's very clearly influenced by Chinse Wuxia serials, but it chose the bad parts to copy and be inspired from.

2. The Armour on Galadrield thankfully isn't quite as bad as from the meme earlier. But you can see (as I mentioned before) Morfydd struggling a bit to raise her arm realistically for a greeting whilst encased inside her armour. She needs to be put on a training regime or something to up her strength so she can pull off scenes better. Again, you can't rely on vfx only to fix stuff; either it needs to be 100% CG so there's no such issues, or you need help from actual shot scenes that carry the in world physics (eg the chain moving; flowing with the swaying motion of Galadriels walk at the end).

3. Speaking or Armour, the other Armour worn by the Dunedain was not done as well as it should have been. It was clearly a plastic as can be seen in some shots, rather than a material scale armour. The prop division needs to get their act together better.

4. The A game remains Elrond and Durin, whilst there's not a lot of scenes really between them this episode, so that's saying a lot, the interactions between them remain the best part in my opinion. All the lies on Elronds side (not by Elrond themself though) would normally torpedo any friendship when trust is an issue and on shakey grounds, but Durin at least heard out Elrond and had a good enough sense of humour about it all. So at least the writers aren't taking a CW approach to stuff and making drama for no reason.
 
Caporegime
Joined
19 May 2004
Posts
32,203
Location
Nordfriesland, Germany
Not sure what the problem with Galadriel's armour is supposed to be. It looks much more like real armour than most fantasy armour. Real plate was 1-3mm thick. Galadriel's armour in that picture looks much closer to real armour than 90% of fantasy armour, it doesn't have lots of needless plates, it just looks simple and practical. Probably a little too practical and unembellished for an elf, and especially for a leader like Galadriel but I think they wanted to give her a more hard nosed pragmatic look, and the plain design and unpolished look works great for that.

I don't object to massively stylised armour like this:

5e9da9c717cac8f868e732ecaad00cac.jpg

But it's nothing like real armour at all.


Whereas this is great - probably because it looks closely based on a real suit - but not all armour was polished.
 
Soldato
Joined
26 Dec 2009
Posts
9,638
Location
North
Not sure what the problem with Galadriel's armour is supposed to be. It looks much more like real armour than most fantasy armour. Real plate was 1-3mm thick. Galadriel's armour in that picture looks much closer to real armour than 90% of fantasy armour, it doesn't have lots of needless plates, it just looks simple and practical. Probably a little too practical and unembellished for an elf, and especially for a leader like Galadriel but I think they wanted to give her a more hard nosed pragmatic look, and the plain design and unpolished look works great for that.

I don't object to massively stylised armour like this:



But it's nothing like real armour at all.



Whereas this is great - probably because it looks closely based on a real suit - but not all armour was polished.

Armour looked fine in this episode from what I saw, I didn’t even notice it prior till someone complained about it so can’t have been that bad. Now if you want to complain about bad armour look no further than some of the sets in The Witcher :D


ahr13kwlt5031.jpg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom