Completed the game last night.
Here be SPOILERS:
Good points:
- Visuals were fantastic. Hugely improved the atmosphere within the game and the general look of characters and places was much less bland than the first game.
- Normal combat was a lot better. Although I liked the stances in the first game I felt there was a lot more freedom in movement within the second. The signs were hugely improved and I much preferred the use of weapons (bombs, traps, etc).
- The voice acting was superb.
- Elements such as crafting, alchemy, etc were actually a necessity on normal difficulty. I ignored these during the first game and it was nice to use features I'd previously considered non-essential.
Bad points:
- Boss fights. Letho, Kayran and the Dragon were real low points for me. I actually quit half way through the Dragon fight the first time I attempted it because I was bored. Up until that point the fights had made sense; you could apply some form of tactics. The dragon seemed tacked on and the fight lacked any spark.
- QTE's did not need to be in this game. Idiotic inclusion that just did not work.
- Ending before it begins. The ending for me was a closure point of a chapter, but not the logical ending point for the game. After the huge prologue and two following chapters, Chapter 3 was very much "blink and you'll miss it". They are definitely holding out for expansion packs.
- The pants on head retarded tutorial system. I like the deep end but this was stupid. Spent most of the first fights using two signs and then trying to block my way out of trouble. I thought my keyboard was broken when I consistently had no response when pressing E.