Poll: United States Grand Prix 2017, Austin - Race 17/20

Rate the 2017 USA Grand Prix out of ten

  • Total voters
    57
  • Poll closed .
RSR said:
It may not have been lasting advantage but it did accelerate off the track, for me its the lack of consistency and also they need to remove some of these run offs as clearly they are too easy to abuse.

We need Eduardo Freitas in charge from the WEC at least they are mostly consistent.
Click to expand...
They are being consistent though in only penalizing drivers that gain a lasting advantage from leaving the track.
 
BuffetSlayer said:
Yeah I know - was being tongue in cheek. Do you feel the enforcement is consistent?
Click to expand...

In this instance of this rule they've been consistent this weekend about where track limits have been relaxed because you don't gain an advantage. Where you gain advantage leaving the track at other corners, the usual rules apply and AFAICT they were enforced for everyone during the race. If it hadn't been a few corners from the end of the race, Verstappen would have been told to give the place back or had a stop go/time added penalty.

In general across the whole year, rule enforcement has been inconsistent, and that's something I hope Liberty Global will fix, and the likes of Vettel's antics this year will not get away with just an ineffectual slap on the wrist.
 
Verstappen clearly cut the corner I'm not sure how anyone can defend that, same with Bottas earlier on he ran wide on the exit which allowed him not to have to brake and he could carry more speed. Both should be penalties.

Hamilton has said pretty much what I've been saying for years - get rid of run offs, they just encourage abuse and reward bad/wreckless driving. F1 is by its very nature a dangerous profession, if the drivers want 100% safety and zero risk get an office job which pays considerably less.
 
Lol, Christian Horner said the four letter S word, "it was a **** decision.." and got told off by Steve Jones, Coulthard, Webber and Jordan for saying it on live TV :D

I'm delighted Lewis is on course to win the championship, but does anyone else cringe just a bit when Lewis shows off on the podium? He generally comes across quite humble, but it's a bit embarassing when he takes over the start of his interviews by bigging up how great the crowd is when really I don't think he cares, it's more like he's just saying 'you all think I'm awesome'. Then pouring champagne down Usain Bolt's back while he was interviewing Kimi.
 
Merlin5 said:
Lol, Christian Horner said the four letter S word, "it was a **** decision.." and got told off by Steve Jones, Coulthard, Webber and Jordan for saying it on live TV.
Click to expand...

It was Webber who said it was a **** decision. The others continued to tell him off after the ad break. He said “sorry whatevs” and then said it was after the watershed so it’s ok.

Big Spender said:
When did he say this?
Click to expand...
Unless he said that in a separate interview, in the one I saw he called one particular steward an idiot, not a retard.

He also said he hopes no one attends the US GP next year; two things EJ called him out on and said he will regret once he’s calmed down.
 
Steampunk said:
All those bits of run off and tarmac were put in for safety reasons, gravel traps having a tendency to flip the car and throw stones all over the track. Plus it allows drivers to rejoin a track rather than go out and have the race yellow flagged while they retrieve the car. The only way the stewards have left to stop the drivers taking the mickey is to punish them when they break the rules.
Click to expand...
For the bikes mainly...
 
Max shouldn't have been penalised given the number of people who weren't. The fia doing what it does best. If the fia don't want that to happen then put gravel or a barrier there.
 
Apparently Hamilton cut that corner pretty heavily on his pole lap. Probably gained a few tenths. FIA being consistent would be such a massive boost to the sport.

Wish they would slam hard on track limits. Those white lines are there for a reason.
 
Merlin5 said:
Lol, Christian Horner said the four letter S word, "it was a **** decision.." and got told off by Steve Jones, Coulthard, Webber and Jordan for saying it on live TV :D

I'm delighted Lewis is on course to win the championship, but does anyone else cringe just a bit when Lewis shows off on the podium? He generally comes across quite humble, but it's a bit embarassing when he takes over the start of his interviews by bigging up how great the crowd is when really I don't think he cares, it's more like he's just saying 'you all think I'm awesome'. Then pouring champagne down Usain Bolt's back while he was interviewing Kimi.
Click to expand...
If you have ever been to a gp you'll know it's refreshing to even acknowledge the fans.
 
Mr Jack said:
Well, watching the replays I can't say that it's a wrong call but I think it's a very harsh one. Technically, they've got a point but actions like that are rarely punished.
Click to expand...

Gaining an advantage by cutting a corner is virtually always punished, unless the offending driver hands the place back.

Horner spouting off about how it's happened all weekend but, as Flibster pointed out, that's been running wide and not cutting corners.

He also, along with some others, raised the Bottas/Verstappen incident. That was the only other case where violating track limits gave a clear advantage and the only reason nothing happened was that Max immediately got past him anyway. Had he not then Bottas would have been told to hand the place back or also received a penalty.

Much as I like Verstappen's talent and general aggressiveness, this was a clear case of overtaking by going off the track and there was no alternative but to penalise him.
Good as he is, he's still immature and arrogant and thinks he can do whatever he likes. We've already had the incidents of weaving in braking zones last year plus the incident at Mexico where he clearly gained an illegal advantage. All anyone seems to remember of that is Vettel's incandescent rage at Charlie over the radio yet he had a valid complaint.

Verstappen needs to start understanding that the rules apply to him too and he can't just drive off the track to get past someone.
 
Flibster said:
So Red Bull and Verstappen are blaming one steward in particular, Garry Connelly for the penalty.
Verstappen cut the corner by over half a meter, when there was easily sufficient space to take the corner with at least one wheel on the track.
Click to expand...

I thought this - he could easily have been a metre to the left and kept a wheel on the white line and he'd have been fine.

Sorry Horner... You are just a shining little wit when things aren't going your way.
Click to expand...

He's always been that way, whether it's stewards decisions or FIA regulations or just general moaning about Mercedes dominance, conveniently forgetting 2010-13. He's an abhorrent little ****.
 
MooMoo444 said:
Apparently Hamilton cut that corner pretty heavily on his pole lap. Probably gained a few tenths. FIA being consistent would be such a massive boost to the sport.
Click to expand...

Were all four wheels off the track by half a meter?

MooMoo444 said:
Wish they would slam hard on track limits. Those white lines are there for a reason.
Click to expand...

Definitely, but they made it pretty clear what was and wasn't allowed this weekend.
 
I would like the exceeding track limits rule more black and white.

If a driver is all 4 wheels off the track (on designated corners if needs be) then straight up penalty regardless or put a barrier in place. Don't let multiple people exceed and pick and choose the penalties.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom