Dragon Age 2 - Finally got it on the cheap and I'm not hating it, surprisingly.
There are the obvious massive faults, which have been stated many times and they are valid. It really does feel like the cash in, shove it out the door project everyone claims it to be, which is sad. Yet I'm enjoying the experience, mostly...
The biggest problem for me though, is Skyrim. That's now set the standard that I want from my worlds, in terms of scale and accessibility. It also defines the way I want to interact with its inhabitants, DA2 has none of that sense of 'immersion'. What it does have is NPC's vanishing after conversations, NPC's just strolling around while all hell breaks loose around them. Or just plain standing around doing nothing... It does make me exclaim "wtf" from time to time.