People are knocking Xbox now because of Kinect but I would bet that the tables will turn by the second half of next gen when developers are making good use of Kinect and PS4 can't offer the same due do their fragmented ps eye userbase.
In reality we arent though, its more the uses of it rather than the technology itself (its best uses are still connected to a PC/robot for non-gaming). However you want to spin it the first Kinect sold very well yet still hasnt made any innovative impact into mainstream games.
The real telling thing is how embarrassed MS appear to be when it comes to gaming and Kinect, I dont think they showcased a single gaming feature using Kinect at E3 during their presentation, yet quite happily showed off Smartglass several times during mainstream game showcases. Its all well and good forcing your customer base into buying an accessory, at least show them why they need it or more importantly why you think theyll be stupid not to have it.
Post E3 all Ive seen Kinect used for in games time and time again, is a glorified microphone with voice recognition, which seems overly expensive if thats all its going to be tasked with, especially when the real tech is within the camera sensors. I think Forzas the only thing that really is better with Kinect (actually Id say essential if you are using cockpit view) if they get head tracking right - its things like this that make me look at Sony and think when you bring out a GT7 on the PS4 you better have this too!
So theres the main reason why I think people frown on Kinect, all we hear is the same potential that we heard years ago when the first Kinect was announced. I dont understand why MS havent done much more with it so when the XO came out it was a bonus Kinect came with it (especially with how much its cost to make) and why they utilised first party studios into only making Kinect games rather than pursue uses for it within mainstream games especially now they force us to pay for it upfront. They seem more than willing to throw money to obtain third party exclusives like Titanfall, why couldnt they throw money at them and say make Kinect essential, make it the decider?
Worse thing that happened to Kinect and the XO is that MS makes it IMHO. Kinect is quite quickly becoming an accessory that really has very little to offer games that we want to play, I dont think its developers/gamers fault if they arent buying into that, it was MSs responsibility nearly 3 years ago to ensure by the time the XO came out we were...
ps3ud0