Looking at Total Biscuits video, iD 5 really is a strange beast when it comes to (the lack) of graphics options. The size of the install is undoubtedly textures, RAGE was the same
I'm not entirely sure what people expect from a shooter though? You hear the whiners roll out the usual stuff, bland / generic / corridor etc. At the heart of it fps games are about killing things, if that mechanic feels satisfying and is challenging then it's job done for me. I don't think the fps genre has particularly evolved for the better, just got easier. The prevalence of "Dad's Army" games has lowered the skill level and increased unnecessary fluff, perks, medals.
Couldn't agree more. Although my favourite genre is fps / rpg, the next best thing for me are fps titles like Quake or Doom. Looks like my kind of game.