My hopes were not particularly high, but this was one hell of an experience!
Positives
- It's Alien...and it nails it! Imo, it fits in perfectly with the movies, and is as much canon as they are.
- Graphics are incredible, really incredible. The games runs really well as well.
- Presentation is absolutely amazing, with first class animations, voice acting and cutscenes. The atmosphere built is perfectly pitched for an Alien game. There are some amazing set-pieces.
- The setting is great. Sevastapol is massive and really well designed.
- The overall story is really good, and there are plenty of twists and turns throughout. Objectives are pretty much always clear(highlights how bad some recent games have been...Watch Dogs, Black Flag etc) and actually make sense which is rare nowadays!
- Some interesting characters, with Amanda Ripley being strong enough to carry a whole game. Audio logs and appearances from original Alien actors are a neat touch as well.
- Stealth gameplay is really good in places, with many ways to get through areas, and some interesting tactics involving craftable items.
- The Alien itself is amazing. Being stalked the whole game by a really designed enemy with great AI that you can't kill makes for some incredibly tense moments, and some of the most memorable pieces of gaming in recent years. Watching(and hearing) The Alien rip through some NPCs is absolutely epic. It has great animations and is absolutely terrifying!
- Sound. Incredible. It helps to create the atmosphere and build tension in a really good way. Perfect.
- Some interesting crafting and extra things to do such as hacking and collecting Audio logs
- There are some specific moments in the game that rank up there as absolute classic moments. I can't tell you about them as it would be a spoiler.
- Overall, I would say the pacing is spot on apart from some issues in the last quarter of the game. The general pacing in terms of breaking up gameplay with different enemies/mechanics worked really well though.
- You can explore a fair bit in the game, though it isn't particularly well implemented tbh.
- The scanner is awesome, a great mechanic that really starts to feel indispensable.
- Half way through the game, you get an item that changes the entire dynamics of your encounters with the Alien. It is really well done and keeps the game fresh.
Negatives
- The game does lose it's way in the last quarter. The last 4 hours should probably be condensed in to about 1, or even cut completely tbh. As it is, the game probably does feel slightly too long.
- The crafting UI is an atrocious piece of design!
- There are some sections early on that can get a bit tedious, mainly involving the humanoid enemies.
- As I mentioned, you can explore the station a fair bit, but there is never any need to really. There are also lots of locked doors that you have to just leave and often never go back to. Imo, the game is really crying out for some side quests. Just something simple, like coming across an NPC who wants you to find something or someone. It might actually give you a reason to explore. As it is though, the story is too tight and focused for exploring to really make sense.
- Lots of backtracking in the last few hours, including one bit that is exactly the same as earlier in the game, with the same enemy doing the same things. Bits like this really do make the game seem repetitive.
Worth mentioning
- The save system. Overall, I thought it worked quite well, but I can understand why some wouldn't. There definitely needs to be some kind of autosave at certain points to stop you from replaying cutscenes etc
- Commits one of the cardinal sins- 'Start New Game' is the first option in the menu, before continue. Schoolboy error!
Overall, I adored this game. At times I found it terrifying, nerve-shredding, tense, exhilarating, at times tedious. It was never short of awesome though. I read a review that called it a game-changer, and I couldn't agree more. It has raised the bar for story-driven action games and brought survival horror back. It isn't just a great Alien game, it is a truly great game!
9.5/10