New Star Trek series - 2017
- Thread starter Spit
- Start date
Associate
Episode 8 and 9 were terrible.
So is dilithium sentient now and responds to emotions on sub dimensional level??? Lololololol 
I enjoyed the series as a whole despite its erm lack of consistency and sense.
I mean the fact a kid screams and kills millions no matter what science they try spin is laughable
I just look at this as a Sci fi show, I didn't watch all the original star treks so I don't compare it too much to them as I can't without seeing them all.
The only star trek I watched start to finish was Voyager which I loved.
I do enjoy this as I enjoyed Picard.
I mean the fact a kid screams and kills millions no matter what science they try spin is laughable
I just look at this as a Sci fi show, I didn't watch all the original star treks so I don't compare it too much to them as I can't without seeing them all.
The only star trek I watched start to finish was Voyager which I loved.
I do enjoy this as I enjoyed Picard.
Man of Honour
- Joined
- 21 Nov 2004
- Posts
- 45,986
It would make for a pretty rubbish enterprise episode...’and, the ship just randomly blew up, the end’
Completely ridiculous. Literally any other scenario would be less ridiculous.
Caporegime
One question.
What race was the holo representation
Of transtrill bf/gf?
Was it bolian? Blue and kinda fishy? I don't think anyone said anything.
The others being human bajoran and I've already forgot.
What race was the holo representation
Of transtrill bf/gf?
Was it bolian? Blue and kinda fishy? I don't think anyone said anything.
The others being human bajoran and I've already forgot.
Soldato
Not Bolian - Adira was rendered as a Xahean (like Po from Season 2 and that Short Trek episode, or Dahj's boyfriend in the first episode of Picard), Gray as a Vulcan but retaining his hair colour because reasons.
***edit***
Also no explanation given as to how the holo matrix could render him visible to Culber and Saru. Because explaining that would have taken screen time away from wanging on about how awesome Burnham is...
Last edited:
Man of Honour
- Joined
- 21 Nov 2004
- Posts
- 45,986
At least she’s finally captain, that makes sense, she’s saved the whole universe single handed several times - hell, I’d put her in charge of star fleet. The thickest plot armour I’ve ever seen on a character.
Man of Honour
- Joined
- 21 Nov 2004
- Posts
- 45,986
I never get tired of the Borg, but then again Burnham is probably immune to assimilation or some such. Hopefully they stick to new adversaries or they’ll just ruin them as they did with the Klingons.
Hopefully season 4 will be the making of the show. They have spent the last 2 seasons trying to undo everything Fuller demand for season 1.
Now they are finally in a place to start afresh. In the future with a rebuilt Federation, upgraded ship and all new uniforms and tech. Its a fresh start so to speak.
Now they are finally in a place to start afresh. In the future with a rebuilt Federation, upgraded ship and all new uniforms and tech. Its a fresh start so to speak.
Man of Honour
- Joined
- 21 Nov 2004
- Posts
- 45,986
It does look like that way, fingers crossed. Seems like a TOS type setup where they are journeying into the unknown of a reset universe. I’ll believe it when I see it though.
Soldato
Thickest plot armour for the thickest, least intelligent character in the Trek universe.
She has to. They can't demote her again, that would be as ridiculous as...well, a 450m long starship having the interior volume of six Borg cubes.
*Spock eyebrow to camera*
In fairness, Voyager already ruined the Borg. Too late for STD's showrunners to screw them up.
I thought Season 2 was supposed to be undoing Fuller and Season 3 would be the making of it?
Hey ho. Whatever it was meant to be, Season 3 at least needed to show some kind of promise that the writers and showrunners actually knew what they were doing.
As it turns out...not so much.
She doesn't have to be demoted she could pass it on, she is too much of a risk taker to be captain imo anyway.
On another note I'd love to see the borg again but haven't they said in the past it isn't possible to bring the borg into this?
I don't even see how Voyager has been referenced as I thought discovery was set away after it
this series of Discovery is set 900 years after the last series. Which originally was before TOS.
There is a ship in Starfleet called Voyager. Its registry ends in J. Meaning there have been many Voyager ships.
Ah that make sense as I couldn't work out how it would be Voyager ship from the series
Soldato
Maybe. But since the Discoball got an A appended just for being refit (something, lest we forget, unheard of in Trek until STD...), there might not have been all that many actually wholly new Voyagers
Soldato
I think the length of the series ruined it. They crammed in too much fluff then left us with a clip show to wrap a couple bits up.
I think the problem with Trek is we've had the best of it, there's not a whole lot of new they could create without rehashing old ideas which long term fans wouldn't like and they obviously want to aim it at new audiences.
Also, turbo lift nonsense, just no.
I have liked it though, so much potential but ultimately it's been wasted on few daft ideas and odd pacing. Saru has been my favourite character. Not sure I are for yet another uniform change and the TOS sounds at the end here. Hopefully it's to hand over to a new showrunner that won't drag too much over a season and we see something new and interesting each episode.
I think the problem with Trek is we've had the best of it, there's not a whole lot of new they could create without rehashing old ideas which long term fans wouldn't like and they obviously want to aim it at new audiences.
Also, turbo lift nonsense, just no.
I have liked it though, so much potential but ultimately it's been wasted on few daft ideas and odd pacing. Saru has been my favourite character. Not sure I are for yet another uniform change and the TOS sounds at the end here. Hopefully it's to hand over to a new showrunner that won't drag too much over a season and we see something new and interesting each episode.