Are you kidding me? Custom coolers are better noise wise, why are you even disputing this?
there are 2 seperate issues regarding the EX OC
"the EX OC will be an excellent overclocker because it has 6+8pin"
this doesn't seem to be true, it comes with a good factory OC but so far people don't seem to be getting much more than that (and from the few reviews available so far, not much further than a reference card is capable of)... but I need more data to draw any conclusions
"the EX OC will be a quiet card because it has an aftermarket cooler"
yes, on stock settings it is quiet, however the one person that has managed a decent overclock from it has said it is "noisy as hell", so if you are buying one because you want to OC it AND you want a quiet card, it also seems to fall down compared with other aftermarket cards
I'm not disputing that an aftermarket card is quieter than stock, however there's a difference between "quieter than" and actually "quiet"... if you wanted quiet AND good OC and didn't get it you might be dissapointed
it comes down to words like "worth" and "value" which are entirely subjective, but I what I would like to see is good advice based on direct experience instead of "it must be x because it has y" based on nothing other than hearsay and rumour, because that is more useful to me as a potential customer for this product (and ultimately OCUK as it avoids me DSR'ing the card because it doesn't do what the forum has led to me to believe it must)