I don't think I spent too much time assessing options - I ended up with the Tempur Comfort Cloud Pillow. I think in part I was a bit disappointed based on the hype in this thread and mismanaged my expectationsWhat didn't you like? me and my wife have had ours for 6-8 years and love them, but I get that it can be a little subjective. I assume you tried the different pillows from Tempur and returned them in the end using the 30 night trial?
I mean it is "fine" but it is no better than the Simba pillows I had before I don't think. I expect it'll outlast the IKEA, Marriott, and Hungarian down ones that I've been compelled to replace after 6-9 months in the past.