I've only had time to play chapter 1 so far, but I've really enjoyed it. Looking forward to having a bit more freedom from now onwards though. I can see why people suggest keeping a save at the start of chapter 2.
Yeah it really opens up after the prologue, which is a glorified tutorial, but an enjoyable one. I loved the weather conditions up in the mountains, it does a good job of showing off the games atmospheric capabilities.
After the 2 hour prologue which I felt was quite restricting and being out in to the open world it feels like a much improved and built on GTA world. I never expected it to feel so alive but casually riding through the landscape leads to all sorts of unpredictable scenarios. It almost feels like the world responds to how you behave like you would expect it to in real life. I fired some shots nearby a fort in the wilderness and after a couple of minutes a patrol was sent out to investigate, and I wasn't even that close but they still took an interest. I haven't touched the main storyline yet and probably won't for a long while, there's plenty of side quests and areas to explore.
I know a lot of people refer to open worlds as being vibrant and feeling alive, but RDR2 puts all the ones I've played to shame, even GTA5 didn't have this level of vitality. And as you said, there's loads to do. The main story itself is very long, and that's without factoring in the stranger missions, treasure maps, the chance encounters, the challenges, the bounties, the gang hideouts, the robberies, the legendary animals, the activities, and that's all just in single player mode. Packed and packed with content. Which is very much welcome as I felt GTA5 was pretty light in the single player department, but they've made up for it 10 fold here.
Superb. Atmospheric. RP potential galore. Some of the best aesthetics I've seen in a game
Agree 100%. I was amazed playing it on console but on PC it is utterly breathtaking to behold. Sometimes I just stop on my horse, go into first person mode and enjoy the scenery. An aesthetic marvel
Fantastic. Totally immersed in it. The environment is amazing and random stuff quite welcomed and unique.
Just been killed by a mountain lion though as I thought would happen at some point.
Just wait until you're playing it at 2am in the morning, in pitch black, with the volume up (or headphones on), enjoying a pleasant ride in the forest, and you get mauled out of nowhere by a bear or another wild animal.