Man of Honour
- Joined
- 5 Jun 2003
- Posts
- 91,562
- Location
- Falling...
There is certainly some merit to staying within a range, typically 10-15% bf. Cut to 10%, bulk until reaching 15%, rinse and repeat. I won't go into the myriad reasons here, but in essence, yes, you're not entirely wrong. That's definitely one way of doing it.
The problem is that getting down to 10-12% bf is NOT DIFFICULT. It can be done fairly quickly and does not require 18 months worth of dieting, as you've been doing. You're probably around about that sort of bf already, if you go for a standard caliper test (e.g. Durnin Womersley). All you're doing now is spinning your wheels, making minimal further progress on fat loss and more or less no progress on muscle gain.
A competitive bodybuilder may take a year to get down from 30-35% bf to stage-shredded. Getting from regular bf levels (15-20%) to 10% can be done in a matter of a few months, maybe even 2 months or less in some instances. Not 18 months.
Getting to a 10-12% BF is easy sure, we can all get there by starving ourselves. Getting to 10-12% and have a lot of muscle mass is certainly not easy. For people who don't care about BB'ing taking a year to knock off 6% BF whilst gaining/retaining muscle mass is a fantastic achievement.
Having had extensive bio-impedence and 10-point calliper tests over the years my weight has stayed around the same bar natural fluctuations, yet bodyfat slowly creeped down over the past 12-18 monts.
Also the difference in bodyfat from 10-15% is massive in appearance.
By all means throw comments out like "losing fat is easy" but losing fat whilst maintaining a good physique is not such a throw away task I'm afraid.