'95 Dredd?
If you don't know the mythology, it's a fairly entertaining (and incredibly camp) flick.
If you do know the mythology, you'd be booing like me and the rest of the 2000AD nerds did at the cinema
It has it's plus points (City design/Angel gang/Better story), but as far as an accurate portrayal of the title character goes... No.
The new film has a much lower budget and a relatively poor/weak story, but it does nail the character of Dredd which is more important to fans like me.
Look at it as just another day in the life of the toughest judge in the big Meg, not a 'Tom Cruise saves the city' style extravaganza.