1. It doesn't need an economy. The only relevant enconomy in SC is the one where pixels are sold to mugs for ludicrous sums to fund Robert's lifestyle and ego.
RDR2 is a open world game which wants to have an economy (after all you buy stuff, sell stuff, gain money, etc.), but is a very basic system behind, as old as the gaming industry, no innovation.
SC and law system aims to emulate the real life one. Atm, is work in progress.
2. Heard all this blather about reactive AI before - this is nothing new.
Cool, do you know of games that actually have very good AI, able to do all the tasks it must perform in SC? Name a few.
3. See above.
?
4. It's beautifully realised world. SC has a few planets representing what menat to be endless space. So hands down win to RDR2 here.
It's work in progress, point was there is far greater work goes into bigger spaceships that goes into a town or two in RDR2.
5. I've seen the NPC's in SC, they look awful, standing around doing nothing, hands on hips, or wierdly positioned, disapearing entirely for no reason, or simply falling throuigh the floor.
Ergo, work in progress.
There is no game dude, so there's no scope to discuss, it's a glorified tech demo with a few weak gameplay loops, there's zero real complexity or depth, it's great marketing allied to some nice visuals to ditsract the Roberts cultists from seeing the bigger picture, and keeping them hyped for yet another round of milking.
It's work in progress, come back when is launched.