With a better screenplay and a director such as Ridley Scott or Christopher Nolan I think it could have been a point or two higher.
Have you seen Prometheus?
![]()
That scene was good although it lasted about 30 seconds, so wasn't enough to raise the standard of the rest of the film.
The film was terribly clichéd and I lost count of the number of times they repeated things for the younger audiences. If you analyse the film objectively without the Star Wars context it was no better than a Michael Bay action film.
Having extrapolated the plot from the other films there wasn't much to work with other than action. It needed more emotion and meaningful characters to make it great. I know a film is good when I'm still thinking about it after leaving the cinema. But Rogue One digested through me faster than the popcorn I ate. With a better screenplay and a director such as Ridley Scott or Christopher Nolan I think it could have been a point or two higher.
the spoilers are only supposed to be in the Rogue one thread bud :/ (says it in the thread title) ive avoided it specifcally because of it lol...
Ahh well it couldnt be as bad as when a work colleague spoiled The Force Awakens for me...you probably know which bit![]()
Yeah but this thread doesn't mention anything about spoilers. Most people in here talk in specifics about certain points of films. It's a review thread after all. Sorry anyway though mate!![]()
Micheal Bay has only ever made one good film, The Rock.
Have you seen Prometheus?
![]()
That's just insulting.Micheal Bay has only ever made one good film, The Rock. To put Rogue One in the same category as any of his other films is as wrong as wrong can be!