OK now I can rip the film to shreds in spoiler mode
I quite liked the two main leads in the first film but they really don’t bother with any character development at all here. I remember finding Maurice quite funny but here he’s stripped of quirkiness. They introduce a new sidekick nun and… they did nothing with her!
All the actors were likeable but feel really underused. If you have flat characters, you have no care for them.
The film generally lacked much needed levity - jokes in the dialogue etc. It’s played very straight and unfortunately that means you’re going to have to find your humour in the horror, totally devastating any chance of this giving you the chills. I was laughing, but it felt like this time I was laughing at it and not with it.
The meat of the horror is a sorry marathon of a character walking off into the dark by themselves whilst an incompetent demon takes its sweet time to do anything. Then when something does happen it’s often something very bombastic and CGI aided. It’s all really quite repetitive.
2/3 of the way in when the characters were asking “what does [the nun] want?!” I was already in wisecracking mode. “A 4090!”, I whispered to my wife.