Caporegime
i have to agree. the fighting is terrible. its just like his whole concept is to let them tire themselves out beating him up, then he hits them when they are knackered. compared to more modern films it just doesnt hold up.
Even before you get to the actual detail of the fighting, it just looks and sounds terrible. There were scenes when I honestly had to force myself to believe they were hitting each other because it's so manifestly clear that they aren't connecting.
And sure, it won oscars for best picture, director and editing, but it won those a long time ago. As I say - maybe you just had to be there.